Sunday, June 22, 2008

The Official Harpy Report from the Bay Area Joint Elysium and Debate

Ladies & Gentlemen,

It is my pleasure to present the Official Harpy Report from the Bay Area Joint Elysium and Debate, hosted by Alex Neidrich, Prince of Greater Berkeley, CA and Daniel Book, Prince of San Francisco, CA.

The First Night was quite peaceful as everyone gathered to enjoy the historic Fox Theatre, as arranged by Keeper Hyashi, of the Greater Berkeley Court. Keeper Shanghi Kelly of San Francisco is to be commended for his ingenious use of misdirection to protect the event by manufacturing a believable, and indeed useable, secondary and public cover locations for security purposes. Due to his ingenuity and ability to spin, the nights passed without incident.
This year did not see a holding of the Annual Joust, as people were far more interested in discussing issues that would be brought forth for the Great Debate on Sunday evening. That or nobody wanted to take a swim in the bay...

I would like to take a moment to thank Primogen Logan of Clan Brujah, Harpy Lilivatti of Greater Berkeley, and Keeper Hyashi of Greater Berkeley for maintaining the security patrol throughout the event, so our citizens and Guests could gather in peace.

The Second Night of the gathering, was held in the War Memorial Opera House in San Francisco, CA as arranged by Keeper Shanghi Kelly. The evening was relaxed and filled with performance, art and discussion.

The performance highlights of the evening included a traditional Tribal sun Dance by Shequatle (etiquette & Spelling to get name correct) of Clan Tremere, a rendition of "My Funny Valentine" by Kristina Larson of Clan Ventrue, the amazing and amusing story "of the Prince of Mice" as told by Shanghi Kelly, the lovely Japanese Fan Dance performed by Miya, of clan Toreador, and the excellent and enlightening poem as read by Jeremiah Chesterfield, of Clan Toreador. Bravo to all of you for fabulous performances!

The most noteworthy artistic displays were the works of Jeremiah Chesterfield, for his intriguing mirror, the sculpture of Amelia Vadaboncoeur, the works of Angel LaRouge, Elena LaRouge, Prince Alex Neidrich, Prince Jackson Riley, Courtney Restax; and the most talked about work, that of the Lady Catherine Franklin.

During their stay, our guests were invited to participate in a Poker Tournament as hosted by Keeper Shanghi Kelly. To all the participants and onlookers, Mr. Kelly would like to announce the following:

"Thirty souls came a knockin
upon a house of cards
Drinking from a glass of dreams
To choke upon the shards

Some souls came for money
Others wished for fame
A few stalked conversation
All reasons for the game

Three days found them wanting
Their well of luck run dry
Except for Thomas of Arizona
Who caused their dreams to die..."

To all those who met upon the field....
My hat is tipped.
To the winner, Prince Thomas Rialto of Arizona
the coin was given...until next year.

Shanghai Kelly ~ Patron Saint of the Silver Tongue"

Thank you Keeper Kelly!

The Second Night of the gathering, was held in the War Memorial Opera House in San Francisco, CA as arranged by Keeper Shanghi Kelly. The evening was relaxed and filled with performance, art and discussion.

The performance highlights of the evening included a traditional Tribal sun Dance by Shequatle (etiquette & Spelling to get name correct) of Clan Tremere, a rendition of "My Funny Valentine" by Kristina Larson of Clan Ventrue, the amazing and amusing story "of the Prince of Mice" as told by Shanghi Kelly, the lovely Japanese Fan Dance performed by Miya, of clan Toreador, and the excellent and enlightening poem as read by Jeremiah Chesterfield, of Clan Toreador. Bravo to all of you for fabulous performances!

The most noteworthy artistic displays were the works of Jeremiah Chesterfield, for his intriguing mirror, the sculpture of Amelia Vadaboncoeur, the works of Angel LaRouge, Elena LaRouge, Prince Alex Neidrich, Prince Jackson Riley, Courtney Restax; and the most talked about work, that of the Lady Catherine Franklin.

The Third Night saw the presentation of the Great Debate, held on the ship Solano. I would like to thank the court of Berkeley as led by Julius Stewart for the massive restoration project that was held in order for us to enjoy the Solano. A special thank you to Keeper Kelly for his additional security and splendid turn as host.

The debate was moderated by Harpy Angel LaRouge, and split by topic. The first subject presented being the question of weather or not the Gangrel should have a Justicar, the Second focusing on the role of the Children of Haqim in the Camarilla. At the beginning of the debate, members of the audience were invited to speak their minds. I would like to congratulate each of our speakers on their passion, their dignity and their insight when speaking.

The Great Debate log is as follows:

THE DEBATE UPON CLAN GANGREL AND THEIR CLAN'S DESIRE FOR A JUSTICAR:

Speaker Plaid Crow of Stockton, CA - spoke in support for Gangrel

Speaker Heather, Seneschal of New Haven, CA –
"I have heard many speak on this topic, I have heard many speak poorly, and I have heard many speak well, I sadly tend to fall in the former. I am not an orator, I am however, what I am, and that is a creature loyal to the Camarilla. Being such I find I think often on what exactly loyalty is, and what it gains us.

There are many kinds of loyalty. There is the loyalty of a pet to a master, there is a loyalty of a friend to a friend, and there is a loyalty between equals. A loyalty between equals is unmatched in its power, that is the only argument I can think to make. "

Speaker Adrian Howl, Then Prince of Sacramento, CA - spoke in support of Clan Gangrel.

Speaker Tobias Hunter –
"That's right, Gangrel were a founding member of the Camarilla, and they left willingly. They decided they didn't want to be a part for whatever reason. They made that decision, let them deal with it. "

Speaker Jeremiah Chesterfield, of Amador, CA –
"One man and a few of his clan decided to leave, but many stayed. They were not consulted by their Justicar before he left, and so it seems that we cannot judge all the Gangrel's loyalty to the Camarilla on the action of their former Justicar, as he left, but many of the clan are still here, and still loyally working for the Camarilla at large. "

Speaker Adoniel Ligatio, of Phoenix, AZ –
"Argued that many in his clan and in other clans serve loyally the Camarilla, and do not require a Justicar for their services. He futher stated that nine years is not long enough of a time since the Gangrel Justicar left the Camarilla to be considering them for re-entry now. "

Speaker Preston Jonas DeWinter, Then Seneschal of Sacramento, CA - Spoke in favor of Clan Gangrel.

Speaker Mathias Fairchilde, Prince of Amador - Spoke in Favor of clan Gangrel.

Speaker Shamus, of Greater Berkely - Spoke in Favor of clan Gangrel.

Speaker Alex Niedrich, Prince of Greater Berkeley –
"No one here I think doubts the loyalty of the Gangrel who stayed with the Camarilla; who defied those who chose to leave. However, one as important as that Justicar, and so many who stood behind him chose to walk out, speaks greater volumes that any of us can say here tonight.
It is entirely reasonable that perhaps at some point the Gangrel should have a Justicar again. I do no feel that this is that time. Perhaps in a few years we shall look and decide that things have changed, I don't know. At this time I do not feel it is appropriate for the Gangrel to have a Justicar again. He left, maybe if he comes back and makes formal apology to those whom he offended things may change. "

Prince Daniel Book, of San Francisco CA -
"My position is very simple when it comes to Clan Gangrel. One Gangrel left. One that they trusted, one that they put there hopes and dreams in, one that was chosen to serve as their Clan's voice. For those of us that are a bit older, this is not unique. Other Justicars have left under similar conditions and taken their clans with them. What is unique in this situation is that we are continuing to hold responsible the clan that did not leave.
Look to your domains ask your princes, ask your harpies... Who left? Who left? Can you think of a name? Think of who they are, think of what they gave the camarilla. Nothing obviously, they are gone. Who left? One individual, a non unique occurrence that we are treating in a unique manner because of these modern times.

Forgiveness is for a clan, the individual should ask for mercy."

Shanghi Kelly Keeper of San Francisco, CA –
"I speak on one mistake, and I paid for it. Everything I had built up when they walked out, I lost. I do not speak tonight on whether a Justicar should happen or not; I will speak to the effects only. I will speak to the strength of an organization. I will speak to the fact that there are members of my clan that are afforded no position, regardless of their merit in certain Domains simply because they do not have a Justicar. That is the only reason. And it is a thin veiled reason. I do not think it is appropriate for the lack of Justicar to be used for the veneer of prejudice. I do not think it is appropriate to spread weakness inside our organization, for those who have given so much, or who are prepared to give, and simply be able to strike them out.
It is hard; these years have been hard. I came to San Francisco and I was told flat out "there will never be a Primogen in San Francisco." That was maybe day one or two and I made a vow to change that. It was a hell of a struggle; I wish everyone had to go through that. It made me stronger. But I had the luxury of a Prince who at least, although said it, would allow his mind to be changed.

There are those out there who will grasp far into this issue, and would deny, regardless of merit, those who would serve with strength and honor. And if that is the only reason they are being denied as such, then I do not blame them for walking or fleeing, or finding somewhere else. But all that does is create a weakness we cannot afford. I have succeeded in this realm, and many of you have succeeded on this coast, many more have been forgotten or shamed by the sins of another, and that is not appropriate. Thank you."

Prince Varity Valerious of Springfield, IL –
"Tonight among us there are great leaders; leaders who have occasionally made mistakes.
When a leader errs, if they are great, they admit their error. On this occasion, that has not been done, to the detriment of the Camarilla.

We are not speaking about individuals who are upset. We are not speaking of a mistake that was made and how we should be dealing with it in the future. We are saying that a man has made an error that damaged the Camarilla as a whole. That means that he was not a great leader and thus we need a great leader in his place.

The whole of the Gangrel did not leave, one man left. We have other powerful people, other great leaders.

Let them come and lead. "

THE DEBATE UPON THE CHILDREN OF HAQIM AND THEIR CURRENT STANDING WITHIN THE CAMARILLA:

Speaker Alec Rosengard Prince of Stockton, CA –
"For those of you who do not know, I was not embraced into the Camarilla. It is well known for the most part that my sire is an infamous Anarch. I chose to become a member of the Camarilla, as the Children of the Haqim have chosen to join the Camarilla. I spent my time earning respect so I would no longer be seen as Probationary. From the actions I have seen from the Children of Haqim in my Domain and in neighboring Domains, they have gone far beyond even what I did for that to be removed. I now hold the position of Prince, so why is it they cannot? They put their lives on the line just as any other would. They are as much a part of our society as anyone else standing, and as such should be afforded the same rights that the rest of us are. That is the one thing I want everyone here to think about. Thank you."

Speaker "They", Primogen of Clan Nosferatu, Los Angeles - spoke against the Children of Haqim, stating that they are being impatient, and that they are not ready to be full members of the Camarila.

Thomas Rialto, Prince of Phoenix AZ –
"Clan Assamite as they will be known permanently in my domain until Justicars tell me differently, have a streak of desire for instant gratification as a whole. I understand that they wish to be called the children of haquim and wish to be separated from their past, but unfortunately it is not as easy as changing their name and telling everyone that they are different or better now. They were known as a clan of assassins, murderers and diablarists for hundreds of years, and as much as I understand that there are individuals who have set themselves apart, that does not give them the right to be granted full admission into the Camarilla.

The other point I would like to make, this is not an either or, or mutually exclusive debate. This is not a yes or no, a compromise can be reached the solution I would like to see would be for princes on an individual basis, make individual decisions about individual Assamites and their right to be fully accepted as full sect, those who would be viewed as no longer probationary, would be allowed to take Prince or Seneschal. We trust our Princes to decide who is worthy to be acknowledged within our great society, why can we not trust them with this responsibility as well?"

Shanghi Kelly Keeper of San Francisco, CA –
"Mr. Kelly stated that he would like to hear the history and stories from the Children of Haqim, as to why their entrance to the Camarilla is a benefit now, as opposed to someday.

He also expressed concern about the feud between the Children of Haqim and other members of the Camarilla, and does not want to see that feud become a war within. He wants to see all parties clearly define and address their issues with one another before the Children of Haqim are given entrance as full members to the Camarilla. "

Gideon Davinci, Primogen of Clan Tremere, San Francisco –
"I stand before you not as an advisor to the Prince, nor as a representative of my Clan. In fact my opinion on this matter is detested by many. I don't know if anyone in this room has sat down with a Child of Haqim, or asked them what their story is. I urge you all to do so.
There story is of one of an incredible journey, in which they have risked everything to come to our shores and seek sanctuary. There are many here who have the opinion that they shouldn't be let in. For the ones who have actually investigated or were there when certain events took place I can understand. But there are certain individuals that are making their decision based on Prejudice, because they can't be bothered to walk across a room and have a conversation.

In the impending year we will all make the decision if they stay and become full members or if they will go. I would just ask humbly that everyone have at least one conversation with them, ask them what their story is, and then make your decision.

Thank you. "

Prince Varity Valerious, Springfield IL –
"Good Evening, I would like to explain why you are listening to me twice.
My domain has been talking about this for months. They are very passionate about this subject, and I am bringing opinions from across the Midwest. In regard to the Children of Haqim, I would like you all just for a moment to put yourself in the position of a Prince. You have two candidates for a job, one of these candidates is exceptionally more qualified. They have mortal influence, they have natural ability. They are socially adept, politically aware, and the other candidate, whilst good, doesn't haven't quite have the natural capability, or hasn't been around as long, and yet you pick the second over the first, because the first cannot be picked.

Does this not weaken the domain? Does this not weaken the Camarilla? Because this domain is now not as strong as it could be, because the person who should have the job can't take it. I think that is the question should be answered, not whether or not the clan as a whole, which is made up of these individuals is capable, but in fact is the Camarilla as a whole is stronger with them in the positions where you can have the best man for the job. "

Gordon, Primogen of Children of Haqim spoke for the Children of Haqim gaining entrance into the Camarilla as full members, as he has stated already.

Prince Book, Clan Tremere, Prince of San Francisco, CA –
"I am betting almost everyone in this room can guess my position on this matter….
and I can bet that you all guessed wrong. The Children of Haqim need to be brought into the Camarilla, there is no question, there is no debate.

The Assamites need to be branded as Enemies of the Camarilla, need to be hunted down and they need to be killed. And these two distinctions need to be made by those who have the right to do so. I would request that the Justicariate take a census, we need to know who is in, and who is out.

Then we must exterminate what would become the Assamites. Because the biggest problem, what we deal with, what we look at, what we have truly come too is that some of the Children of Haqim answer to a different master, outside the Camarilla and that is unacceptable. Those masters must be with us, or be destroyed or they become much like the Sabbat.

Very simply put, the Children of Haqim have earned a place at our table. They have earned the rights to be our Seneschals, they have earned the right to take Domains and make them their own. I would like to take voices to Conclave, and say let us bring them in, let us make the Camarilla whole, and let us then take the enemies to the Camarilla, those who we would then call Assamites, and bring them to heal. Bring them to dust.

Then we can focus on the Sabbat.

We have spent too many years of energy and debate on this issue, and we are not any further along. This is the only thing that could heal this wound. We cannot survive without the Children of Haqim, not in these days, not in these nights. "

Prince Alex Neidrich, of Greater Berkeley, CA –
"I would like to thank those who have already chosen to speak, this is a matter of great importance to all of us. A number of people have spoken with a little more eloquence that I may, and I am kind of surprised with the voices that have sounded. But I think this is important. Through discussion we can strengthen the Camarilla, and by bringing the Children of Haqim fully into the Camarilla I think we can strengthen it.

There are many who would point to past transgression by small numbers of what really should be known as the Assamites and not the Children of Haqim as reasons why we should not allow these great members fully into the Camarilla. This is the same as pointing at any few of any clan and saying "because some of you are bad, all of you are. And I would like to think that most of us could get past some of that.

I think that Prince Book kind of epitomizes that at the moment. The Camarilla has many enemies. There are wars that we are fighting in many Domains and in some they are winning. Let us take the hand that has been extended, and let us welcome the Children of Haqim into the Camarilla so that we may be stronger, and conquer all of our enemies.

Matters of Standing:

Prince Alex Niedrich did not have any matters of standing to address at the event. As is tradition for the Court of San Francisco, Prince Book conducted his annual review of the contributions of the San Francisco Court and Her Visitors, and made the following announcements over the course of the weekend:

For constantly going forth to assist the city in security, culture and the arts, Jeremiah Chesterfield was seen as Fearless.

For risking his existence capturing the lone Sabbat that managed to slip past the Domains security when under no compulsion to do so, Peter Premsyl, Seneschal of Sacramento, CA is to be seen as Dutiful.

For advice rendered to Prince Book, even when such advice was not what Prince Book wanted to hear, William Stanford Ventrue Primogen of San Francisco, CA is to be seen as Stoic.

For his assistance to San Francisco, and his efforts which have saved much hardship, Thomas Rialto, Prince of Phoenix AZ, is to be seen as Dedicated.

For his numerous investigations and insights into issues facing the Domain, as well as vital information that he always seems to have at crucial moments, Trent, Seneschal of San Francisco is to be seen as Insightful.

For his continuous sage advice, and steadfast aide to the City of San Francisco, Mark Richardson, of Primogen of Clan Malkavian, San Francisco, CA is to be seen as Enlightened.
For his service to San Francisco in battle, political, influential and physical Shanghi Kelly, Keeper of San Francisco, is to be seen as Feared.

For his service to San Francisco in battle, political, influential and physical Gideon Davinci, Tremere Primogen of San Francisco, is to be seen as Feared.

For his work during investigations, as well as the advice lent to Prince Book during difficult decisions, Charlie Kesch of San Francisco, CA is to be seen as Insightful.

Further commendation was given to Primogen Sandra of Clan Nosferatu. She has been tirelessly working upon issues that plague the city, as well as working with her clan mates to strengthen San Francisco politically and structurally. Thank you Primogen Sandra!

Prince Book would like to be known, that as upsetting as it is to deny any member of the Camarilla his hospitality, he must declare that Wendel of Clan Gangrel is no longer welcome, nor will he gain his Hospitality, for Wendal's excessively rude behavior, even to his own clan mates.

Prince Book also took the time to point out the bad behavior of one of his visitors, so Jacob Hill may serve as an example to all as what one must never do. Jacob Hill of Clan Brujah sat and laughed as his clan mate killed Harpy Zahn of New Haven, CA. All three were Brujah, and since Jacob Hill decided he would not save his clan mate from death, he is to be known as "Giggles" in San Francisco hereafter.

This concludes the report from Greater Berkeley and San Francisco, CA. We would like to thank all of our guests for attending, and wish you all many peaceful nights.

Harpy LaRouge
San Francisco, CA

No comments: